The Ultimate Guide to the Best Pizza in Orlando

March 1, 2022 | Jordan Silvola-Finch
The Ultimate Guide to the Best Pizza in Orlando

Check out this guide to the best pizza in Orlando, it is bound to ensure that you find the perfect piece of the pie.

Orlando, Florida is a great place to enjoy some delicious pizza. With a wide selection of restaurants offering everything from classic Italian dishes to creative and modern twists on the classic dish, Orlando has something for every pizza lover. Whether you’re looking for an inexpensive slice or a gourmet meal with all the trimmings, there are plenty of options that will leave you feeling full and satisfied. Here’s why Orlando FL is a great place to get your pizza fix:

First and foremost, Orlando boasts many acclaimed pizzerias serving up top-notch pies in both traditional and innovative styles. From thin crust Neapolitan-style wood fired pizzas to thick, crunchy Chicago-style deep dish slices, Orlando has something for everyone. You can also find creative pies topped with locally sourced ingredients and freshly made sauces that will tantalize your taste buds.

Second, pizza in Orlando is incredibly affordable. With so many restaurants to choose from, prices are competitive and you can easily get a great deal on a delicious meal. Not only that, but some places even offer daily specials or discounts on takeout orders, making it easy to stick to your budget while still enjoying quality pizza.

Third, the atmosphere of Orlando’s pizzerias makes dining out an enjoyable experience. From cozy family-run joints to hip eateries serving up gourmet slices, there’s something for everybody when it comes to finding the perfect spot to enjoy some pizza. The friendly and inviting atmosphere makes it easy to relax, grab a bite to eat, and have a great time with friends or family.

Finally, if you’re looking for something unusual or unique when it comes to your pizza experience in Orlando, there are plenty of options. From vegan pizzas topped with fresh produce to Sicilian-style pies cooked up with locally sourced ingredients, there’s no shortage of creative ways to enjoy the classic dish. With so many choices available, you can always find something new and interesting when it comes to getting your pizza fix in Orlando FL.

Ultimately, Orlando is an ideal destination for any pizza lover looking for quality food at affordable prices served up in a fun and inviting atmosphere. With so many restaurants to choose from and a wide range of styles available, you’re sure to find the perfect spot for your next pizza night out in Orlando FL. So go ahead and indulge in some delicious pizza—because Orlando is definitely the place to be!

Best pizza places in Orlando by Google score and reviews

Business NameScoreReviews
Antonella’s Pizzeria Fairbanks4.7512
Pizzeria Del-Dio Italian Restaurant4.6426
Buttercrust Pizza4.683
Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza4.51,217
Pizza Bruno4.41,317
NYPD Pizza Metro West4.4696
Armando’s Cucina Italiana & Pizzeria4.4383
A Slice of New York Pizza4.3459
Via Napoli Ristorante e Pizzeria at Epcot4.21,038
F&D Woodfired Italian Kitchen4.2524

Best Pizza Places in Orlando by Category

Best New York Style Pizza in Orlando

Nothing beats New York-style pizza, even in the Sunshine State. Handcrafted, big slices and perfect for on the go or as a treat at home. Its winning combination of a deliciously thin base and thick crusts makes it perfect to be folded and eaten. These top 3 new york style pizzas will leave you questioning whether you really are in Orlando. Even native New Yorkers haven’t been able to taste the difference, so if this is your pizza of choice you are in for a treat. From Winter Park to Kissimmee, browse Orlando’s best pizza now.

Antonella’s Pizzeria

Antonella’s Pizzeria
Antonella’s Pizzeria – Image capture: Dec 2017 – URL

Antonella’s Pizzeria in Orlando, FL is a destination worth visiting for pizza lovers. Located near the heart of downtown Orlando, Antonella’s offers delicious Italian cuisine and an atmosphere that cannot be matched. From their classic pizzas to unique creations, there is something for everyone on the menu. The restaurant has been around since 1983, making it one of the longest-running establishments in the area. Here are four reasons why you should visit Antonella’s Pizzeria in Orlando, FL:

First and foremost, Antonella’s serves up some of the best pizza around. From traditional pies like pepperoni or sausage to unique combinations like veggie Hawaiian or BBQ chicken, they have something for everyone. The dough is made fresh each day and the ingredients are always top-notch, making for a delicious pizza experience. Their menu also features other Italian favorites like calzones, subs, soups and salads.

Second, Antonella’s has an inviting atmosphere that will make your dining experience even more enjoyable. With its brick walls and old school Italian decor, it feels like you’ve stepped into Italy when you walk in the door. Plus, their friendly staff ensures that every customer feels welcome and appreciated.

Third, Antonella’s Pizzeria offers plenty of options for takeout or delivery so you can enjoy their great food at home too! Whether you want to pick up a few pies for a family gathering or have them delivered to your office, they make it easy.

Finally, Antonella’s Pizzeria has an extensive catering menu that is perfect for any special event. From small gatherings to large corporate functions, their staff will work with you to create the perfect menu and ensure your party is a success. They also offer discounts on larger orders so you can save money while still having delicious food.

With its delicious pizza and inviting atmosphere, Antonella’s Pizzeria in Orlando, FL is definitely worth visiting! Whether you want to dine-in or order takeout or delivery, they have something for everyone. Plus, their catering services are top-notch for any event. So come on down and experience the best pizza in town!

Find Antonella’s Pizzeria at two locations in Winter Park.

NYPD Pizza

NYPD Pizza Metro West
NYPD Pizza Metro West – Image capture: Apr 2021 – URL

NYPD Pizza in Orlando, FL is a must-visit destination for pizza and Italian cuisine lovers. Located at the heart of International Drive, NYPD Pizza offers an incredible selection of pizzas, pastas, calzones and sandwiches with options to please all palates.

First of all, NYPD Pizza’s menu features classic Italian favorites such as Lasagna, Spaghetti Carbonara and Fettuccine Alfredo as well as some unique creations like the Coney Island Dog Pie or the Proscuitto & Arugula Calzone. All dishes are made from fresh quality ingredients that makes every meal a special experience. Plus, they serve generous portions which means you’ll have enough to share or save for later.

NYPD Pizza also offers an impressive selection of craft beers, wines and spirits to pair with your meal. From domestic favorites to artisanal selections, you’ll have plenty of options to choose from. They also have an extensive list of specialty cocktails that are sure to make any night out even more special.

Finally, NYPD Pizza has a lively atmosphere which makes it the perfect spot for group gatherings or date nights. The friendly staff will ensure you’re served quickly and politely while the cozy interior setting creates just the right mood for relaxed conversations over delicious food. So if you’re visiting Orlando, be sure to drop by NYPD Pizza for a meal you won’t soon forget.

Find NYPD Pizza at 6 locations throughout the metropolitan Orlando area.

A Slice of New York Pizza

A Slice Of NY Pizza
A Slice Of NY Pizza -mage capture: Jul 2021 – URL

A Slice of New York Pizza in Orlando FL is a must-visit for any pizza lover. This pizzeria strives to bring authentic New York-style pizza right to the heart of Florida! The restaurant has all the classic pizzas that you know and love, but they also have a variety of specialty pizzas made with fresh, locally sourced ingredients. The atmosphere at A Slice of New York Pizza is warm and inviting; it’s the perfect spot for family dinners or just an evening out with friends.

One of the best things about A Slice of New York Pizza is their commitment to making delicious, quality food. All their pies are made from scratch using only the freshest ingredients available. They even use homemade sauces that are cooked from family recipes! The crusts are crispy and crunchy on the outside, but still light and fluffy on the inside—it’s like biting into a piece of heaven.

Another reason to visit A Slice of New York Pizza is for their wide selection of toppings. From classic pepperoni to unique ingredients like artichokes and pineapple, there’s something for everyone. And if you’re not feeling adventurous enough to try something new, they also have plenty of traditional favorites as well. No matter your pizza preferences, A Slice of New York Pizza has an option that will make your taste buds sing!

Finally, it’s hard to top the friendly service at A Slice of New York Pizza. The staff is knowledgeable and always happy to help you find the perfect pizza. They’re also more than willing to accommodate special requests, so you can get exactly what your heart desires! Whether you’re a local or just passing through Orlando FL, A Slice of New York Pizza should be at the top of your must-visit list. With their mouthwatering pizzas, vast topping selection, and excellent customer service—you’ll never want to go anywhere else. So come on down and experience it for yourself! You won’t regret it.

Best Deep Dish Pizza in Orlando

Deep-dish pizza, also known as Chicago-style pizza, is a thick pizza baked in a pan and piled with cheese, meat and vegetables, and sauce. Because of the oil in the pan, the crust is normally two to three inches tall and slightly cooked and crispy. The biggest difference between deep-dish pizza and other popular styles is that the dough is exceptionally thick, resulting in a bulky pizza that resembles more of a pie rather than its flatbread-styled cousins. The crust is thin to medium in thickness, despite the fact that the overall pizza is fairly thick. Either way all you know is it is delicious. And, these are our recommendations on where to get the best deep dish pizza in Orlando.


Giordano’s – Image capture: Jan 2022 – URL

Giordano’s Pizza in Orlando, FL is the perfect place to satisfy your pizza craving. From thin crust to deep dish pizzas, they have something for everyone. The freshly made dough and premium ingredients make every bite unforgettable. The classic Chicago-style stuffed pizza is a fan favorite and the Italian sausage topping will keep you coming back for more.

Not only does Giordano’s offer delicious traditional pizzas but their specialty pies are sure to tantalize your taste buds as well. Their BBQ Chicken Pizza features smoked Gouda cheese and zesty barbecue sauce while their farmhouse Bacon & Onion comes topped with crispy bacon, grilled onions, garlic herb ricotta and mozzarella cheese.

Giordano’s also offers a wide variety of appetizers and salads to start your meal off right. From cheese sticks and garlic Parmesan wings to the classic Italian salad, there’s something for everyone. If you’re looking for something a bit more substantial they offer calzones, lasagna and other entrees that are sure to fill you up.

Giordano’s is the perfect place for date night or family dinner. With an inviting atmosphere, friendly staff and top-notch pizza, it’s no wonder why people keep coming back again and again. So make sure to check out Giordano’s Pizza in Orlando next time you find yourself craving a delicious slice of pizza. You won’t regret it!

Find Giordano’s in Kissimme, off Sand Lake Road and International Drive, and near Disney World.

Buttercrust Pizza

Buttercrust Pizza
Buttercrust Pizza – Image capture: Nov 2021 – URL

When you visit Buttercrust Pizza in Orlando, FL, you’re getting the absolute best pizza in town. Their pizzas are handmade with only the freshest ingredients and topped with a unique blend of seasonings that will tantalize your taste buds. Their dough is made from scratch every day for an unforgettable experience.

At Buttercrust Pizza, you can customize your pizza to whatever toppings and flavors you wish. Whether it’s traditional pepperoni or something more adventurous like pineapple and jalapenos, they have something that everyone can enjoy. They also offer gluten-free crust upon request so all diners can partake in their delicious creations.

The atmosphere at Buttercrust Pizza is perfect for a night out with friends or family. It’s laidback and inviting, making it easy to relax and enjoy your meal. They offer an extensive selection of craft beers and wines so you can pair perfectly with your pizza.

Not only does Buttercrust Pizza make fantastic pizzas, they also have amazing sandwiches and salads that are just as delicious. Their signature sandwich is the “Buttercrust Burger” which has a juicy patty topped with bacon, cheese, pickles, and their special sauce. If you’re looking for something lighter but still satisfying, try one of their crisp salads made with fresh ingredients.

Buttercrust Pizza is just south of Downtown Orlando on South Orange Avenue.

Best Wood Fired Pizza in Orlando

Cooking in a wood-fired pizza oven guarantees that temperatures will rise. Being cooked in this hot oven the pizza cooks quickly and the moisture generated from the sauce, cheese, and topping burns away ensuring that you won’t end up with a soggy or greasy crust. 

F&D Wood Fired Italian Kitchen

F&D Woodfired Italian Kitchen
F&D Woodfired Italian Kitchen – Image capture: Feb 2021 – URL

F&D Wood Fired Italian Kitchen in Orlando, FL is a highly rated restaurant that brings Italian dishes to life with the flavors of wood-fired cooking. Their menu offers classic dishes such as pizza and pasta, as well as unique specialties like grilled octopus and fried artichokes. The chefs at F&D not only craft incredible flavor combinations with their wood-fired cooking technique, but they also put an emphasis on freshness, sourcing local ingredients whenever possible.

Visiting F&D Wood Fired Italian Kitchen in Orlando means being able to experience fresh, delicious Italian food made with care and passion for its guests. Not only do they serve some of the best Italian food around town, but their wood-fired cooking gives their dishes a unique, smoky flavor that will have your taste buds singing.

Another reason to visit F&D Wood Fired Italian Kitchen is their amazing atmosphere. The restaurant is cozy and inviting, with beautiful decor and an attentive staff that makes you feel like part of the family. Whether you’re dining alone or with friends, the atmosphere at F&D ensures everyone feels welcome and comfortable.

F&D Wood Fired Italian Kitchen in Orlando is truly one-of-a-kind restaurant that offers excellent food and superb service. From its wood-fired cooking techniques to its dedication to using fresh ingredients, it’s no wonder this establishment has become so popular among locals and visitors alike! If you’re looking for an unforgettable Italian dining experience, then you should definitely visit F&D Wood Fired Italian Kitchen. You won’t regret it!

Get some of the best pizza in Orlando at F&D Wood Fired Italian Kitchen locations in Winter Park, Longwood, and the Delaney Park area.

Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza
Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza – Image capture: Sep 2020 – URL

Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza in Orlando, FL is one of the best pizza places you could ever visit. Here, you can find amazing coal fired pizzas that are sure to please your taste buds. The restaurant offers a unique blend of flavors and textures that make it truly stand out from other pizza places. From hand-tossed dough to homemade sauces and fresh ingredients, Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza is sure to give you an unforgettable experience.

One of the things that really sets this restaurant apart is its use of coal fired ovens. These ovens heat up to over 800 degrees Fahrenheit and cook pizzas in just minutes! This ensures that each slice gets a crisp crust with the perfect balance of melted cheese and delicious toppings. The coal fired ovens also add a unique smoky flavor that you won’t find at any other pizza joint in town.

Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza takes pride in using the freshest ingredients for their pizzas. They use only the highest quality tomatoes, mozzarella cheese, and other toppings to ensure that each slice is packed with flavor. Their menu features a wide range of options for both meat eaters and vegetarians alike. From classic Italian-style pies to specialty pizzas like the “Fig & Prosciutto” or “Buffalo Chicken”, there is something here to please everyone.

Finally, Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza is a great place to enjoy with friends and family. The restaurant is always full of fun, lively people enjoying delicious food together. You can grab a seat at the bar or find a spot in one of their cozy booths for an enjoyable evening out. Plus, there are plenty of options for carryout orders if you don’t feel like dining in.

With its coal-fired ovens, fresh ingredients, and friendly atmosphere, Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza is definitely worth visiting in Orlando, FL! Whether you’re looking to share some tasty slices with friends or order up takeout for a quick and easy meal at home, this pizza joint has it all. Stop by today and see what all the hype is about. You won’t be disappointed!

Check out the menu at Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza and find an Italian-inspired delight.

Pizza Bruno

Pizza Bruno
Pizza Bruno – Image capture: Jun 2016 – URL

Pizza Bruno in Orlando, FL is the perfect place to satisfy your pizza craving. Not only will you find delicious pizza options on the menu, but there are many other reasons why you should visit Pizza Bruno.

First off, the atmosphere of Pizza Bruno is unbeatable. Upon entering this vibrant pizzeria, guests are greeted with a warm smiling face from one of their friendly staff members. The restaurant offers ample seating and an inviting decor that creates a relaxing atmosphere for all patrons. Whether you’re looking to have a casual meal or to celebrate a special occasion, Pizza Bruno has everything you need in order to make it memorable.

Another reason to visit Pizza Bruno is the variety of tasty toppings they offer on their pizzas. From the classic mushroom and pepperoni to their more unique creations like smoked salmon and sun-dried tomatoes, there’s something for everyone no matter what your tastes are. Even better, each pizza is prepared with fresh ingredients that keep guests coming back for more every time.

Lastly, Pizza Bruno is known for its unbeatable customer service. The staff is always friendly and accommodating to ensure that every guest has a pleasant experience from start to finish. They are also very knowledgeable when it comes to menu items so you can feel confident knowing they will be able to recommend the perfect pizza based on your preferences.

For all of these reasons, visiting Pizza Bruno in Orlando, FL should definitely be at the top of your list. With delicious pizza, a vibrant atmosphere, and excellent customer service, it is easy to see why this pizzeria has become so popular in the area. So go ahead and give them a try – you won’t regret it!

Find Pizza Bruno on Curry Ford Road in Orlando.

Overall Best Pizza in Orlando

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Orlando, you need to know the next three restaurants. More than just pizzerias, these are true destinations to indulge.

Armando’s Cucina Italiana & Pizzeria

Armando's College Park
Armando’s College Park – Image capture: May 2021 – URL

Armando’s Cucina Italiana & Pizzeria in Orlando, FL is a must visit for anyone looking for delicious and authentic Italian cuisine. Located just off of I-4 and International Drive, the restaurant offers an exquisite selection of Italian dishes from classic lasagna to gourmet pizzas drizzled with fresh olive oil. This establishment has been serving up great food since 1985 and continues to bring something new and special to their menu every year. The atmosphere at Armando’s is always warm and inviting, making it a perfect spot to relax with family or friends while enjoying some classic Italian favorites.

When you come to Armando’s Cucina Italiana & Pizzeria you will have the opportunity to sample some of the best Italian dishes in town. The menu offers an array of delicious options, like their famous hand-tossed pizzas, made with fresh ingredients and cooked in their wood fired oven. There are also pastas, calzones, salads and sandwiches that you can choose from as well as a full bar where you can find your favorite alcoholic beverages to pair with your meal.

One of the things that truly sets Armando’s apart is their commitment to using locally sourced ingredients when preparing their meals. All of their pasta sauces are created right in house using only high quality tomatoes, spices and herbs found right here in Orlando. This ensures that no matter what dish you choose it will be fresh, flavorful and truly authentic.

Armando’s also offers outdoor seating and a comfortable patio area for those who want to take in the gorgeous Florida sunshine while enjoying their Italian feast. With friendly wait staff and passionate chefs, you can rest assured that your experience at Armando’s Cucina Italiana & Pizzeria is sure to be an enjoyable one. So come on down and see what this Orlando staple has to offer! You won’t regret it!

Via Napoli Ristorante e Pizzeria at Epcot

Via Napoli Ristorante e Pizzeria
Via Napoli Ristorante e Pizzeria – Image capture: Sep 2021 – URL

If you are looking for a one-of-a-kind dining experience at Disney World’s Epcot Theme Park in Orlando, Florida, then Via Napoli Ristorante e Pizzeria is the place to go. This Italian restaurant serves up classic Neapolitan cuisine in an atmosphere that will make you feel like you have been transported to Italy itself.

The menu at Via Napoli features several traditional Italian dishes including pizza, pasta, and salads. The pizzas are made with authentic ingredients and cooked in wood-burning ovens imported from Naples, Italy. The dough is light and crispy making the perfect base for any of their signature toppings such as fennel sausage, prosciutto di parma, or mushrooms. The pasta dishes are made with fresh ingredients and cooked to perfection in the ovens. There is also a wide variety of salads featuring seasonal ingredients from local farmers.

One of the best parts about dining at Via Napoli is the atmosphere. You will be surrounded by rustic decor such as large copper pots, exposed brick walls and arched ceilings creating an authentic Italian feel. You can even watch as your food is prepared in one of the wood-burning ovens before being served up to your table for you to enjoy.

No matter what time of day you choose to visit Via Napoli Ristorante e Pizzeria, you can expect a unique experience that will make your trip memorable. With its delectable Italian cuisine, picturesque setting and warm atmosphere, you will surely not be disappointed. So treat yourself to a trip to Italy without ever having to leave the comfort of Epcot in Orlando, Florida.

Admission to Epcot is required to dine at Via Napoli and reservations are highly suggested. 

Pizzeria Del-Dio

Pizzeria Del-Dio Italian Restaurant
Pizzeria Del-Dio Italian Restaurant – Image capture: Mar 2021 – URL

Pizzeria Del-Dio in Orlando FL is a must-visit destination for pizza lovers! Their traditional Italian recipes have been perfected over the years and each dish is cooked to perfection using only the freshest ingredients. Whether it’s a classic Margherita or an unusual toppings combination, you can be sure that your meal will be delicious. They offer both dine-in and takeout options so you can enjoy their delicious creations at home or in their cozy dining room.

What sets Pizzeria Del-Dio apart from other restaurants is their commitment to authenticity. All of their pizzas are made with imported Italian ingredients, including San Marzano tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, and a special house-made dough. The result is a pizza that tastes like it came straight from Napoli – thin and crisp crust with the perfect balance of sweet tomato sauce and savory toppings.

Aside from the pizza, Pizzeria Del-Dio also offers an array of Italian entrees such as their signature lasagna, eggplant Parmigiana, and homemade pastas. Each dish is made fresh to order so you can be sure that whatever you choose will be delicious! Plus they have an extensive wine list featuring some of Italy’s finest wines to complement your meal perfectly.

Visiting Pizzeria Del-Dio in Orlando FL is not just about the food – it’s about the experience. From the friendly staff to the cozy atmosphere, you’ll feel right at home in this charming Italian restaurant. Whether you want to dine-in or takeout, Pizzeria Del-Dio is sure to please your taste buds and make your visit one to remember! So what are you waiting for? Come and enjoy a slice of Italy today at Pizzeria Del-Dio!

It’s time to experience true Italian flavor with an irresistible meal from Pizzeria Del-Dio in Orlando FL! With their authentic recipes and fresh ingredients, you can be sure that your pizza will be cooked just right every time. Plus they offer an array of Italian classics like lasagna and eggplant Parmigiana, plus an impressive wine list to boot. So why wait? Come to Pizzeria Del-Dio today for a truly unique Italian dining experience!

Find Pizzeria De-Rio right across from Orlando’s Fashion Square Mall.

Taste The City Beautiful with Orlando’s Best Pizza

Overall, you will find that you are spoiled and will have so much choice when it comes to taming those pizza cravings. Whoever said that Italy was the home of Pizza clearly had never visited Orlando and found these top-rated pizzerias. 

Whether you want the thin base and thick crust of the New York-style pizza, deep dish, wood-fire cooked pizza, you are bound to find a restaurant that will satisfy the fussiest of pizza eaters. You might even have to try them all. 

Orlando is more than a foodie destination for great pizza. It is also a great place to call home. Learn more about The City Beautiful by contacting us today for a free Orlando home guide.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

crossmenuchevron-down linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram